I've spent some time with the Literary Study Bible and am really enjoying it and highly recommend it.
I generally don't enjoy study Bibles. I think they can distract Christians from reading and discovering the meaning of Scripture for themselves by encouraging people to read Scripture in a choppy way: verse or two, check the study notes, verse, cross-references, study notes, another verse, etc. Study notes can be very helpful if used correctly, but I've never seen a Christian use them in a way that I've found very helpful.
The ESV-LSB removes those bold section headings and cross-references and instead gives a shaded box with brief guidance before each chapter or two, or section or pericope of Scripture. So you start with some guidance concerning the genre, literary structure, techniques, symbolism, whatever. Then you read the passage (single-column) without distraction. That means the emphasis isn't on finding your favorite verse or cheating to get the meaning through headers or notes. The emphasis is to read it yourself and focus on getting the gist of larger sections of Scripture.
The ESV-LSB provides notes before each book of Scripture, which is in pretty much every study Bible. These are really well done. What I liked the most was the section in each book introduction describing how the book fits into the larger "story of the Bible." Brilliant. So you aren't just getting the understanding of larger sections of Scripture, or even whole books. You are also gaining understanding of how the books work together in the storyline of Scripture.
This Bible also has wider margins for your own notes and their own Bible reading plan at the end. It's easily my favorite study Bible and I hope many of you pick it up. And by the way, one of the editors of the ESV-LSB is Dr. Leland Ryken who has produced many great books including two favorites of mine: The Christian Imagination and The Liberated Imagination. Even more reason to love this study Bible.
To see it for yourself, check it out for free online for 30 days. Very helpful.
Other stuff to check out...
Literary ESV is Unapologetically Complementarian
Interview with Dr. Leland Ryken
Internet Monk's Glowing Review
i've been using the NLT Notemakers Bible
Posted by: revolutionfl | 11/03/2007 at 12:59 AM
I just discovered Ryken's Bible Handbook (via Amazon.com). It looks like it's pretty much the same commentary on "the Bible as literature" that the ESV-LSB offers but without the Scripture text, and it's only about $14.
I really like my pocket-sized ESV (no cross-references in the margins but it does have chapter headings) that I've had for a few years. And I've had it long enough that I can find stuff in there w/o knowing the specific chapter and verse. So I'm leery of buying a new Bible, and I'm probably going to put the Ryken Bible Handbook on my Christmas list instead of the ESV-LSB.
It seems like the only thing I would be missing out on is having the single column Bible that reads more like a story (without the chapter headings).
Posted by: Wes H | 11/03/2007 at 03:43 PM
Thanks for the tip, Steve. Just signed up for the 30-day demo and may buy unlimited online access after that.
Posted by: Rae Whitlock | 11/07/2007 at 02:44 PM